On September 16, 2026, a federal court granted an injunction that blocks the implementation of New Mexico’s regulations that would have required manufacturers to put a label on products containing intentionally added PFAS that are sold or distributed in the state. On October 16, 2026, New Mexico filed a notice of appeal in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit challenging aspects of the district court’s injunction order; the labeling rule is currently stayed while the litigation and the appeal are pending.
Background: New Mexico’s PFAS Protection Act (the “Act”) was enacted in 2025 and put into place a phased sales ban on categories of products containing intentionally added PFAS (with limited exceptions and exemptions); imposed a reporting requirement on manufacturers of products containing PFAS; and granted state regulators the ability to make rules, including rules concerning labeling of products containing PFAS. Under the authority granted by the Act, the New Mexico Environmental Improvement Board (“NMEIB”) adopted a rule in May 2026 to require manufacturers to add a label, containing the outline of a laboratory flask with “PFAS” inside it, to any product containing intentionally added PFAS. Under the final rule as adopted, the required label would contain no other information or wording. The New Mexico Environmental Department’s July 2026 guidance document included example graphics such as the following:

The Litigation and Injunction: In American Chemistry Council, et al. v. Kenney, et al., the plaintiffs challenged the labeling rule on First Amendment grounds, contending that the label amounted to compelled commercial speech that bore no rational relationship to any valid state interest. Plaintiffs sought an injunction blocking the rule from going into effect. The District Court agreed with the plaintiffs in part, concluding that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on the merits on the argument that the rule was not a reasonable fit to the State’s asserted interests.
The Court noted that states may have a valid interest in compelling commercial speech in the form of labels in certain circumstances. Here, however, the Court found a disconnect between New Mexico’s asserted interests in consumer awareness, public health, and environmental protection, on the one hand, and the fact that the required label contained no information in the nature of a warning about health or safety hazards, any consequences of exposure, or any instruction to consumers about how to avoid exposure.
The Court concluded that the State’s interest in protecting consumer and environmental health was not sufficient to justify the compelled label, because the label conveyed nothing other than factual information about the content of the product rather than any sort of warning, and “consumer awareness” was insufficient justification alone to support the labeling rule. The Court held that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on the merits of those aspects of their claim, that the harm from the compelled speech would be irreparable to the plaintiffs, and that the balance of interests weighed in plaintiffs’ favor given the First Amendment rights at issue, and thus enjoined the January 1, 2027 labeling deadline while litigation on the full merits continued.
On October 16, 2026, New Mexico filed a Notice of Appeal in the Tenth Circuit, limited to the portions of the injunction order holding that the labeling rule is unlikely to pass rational basis scrutiny.
We will provide updates on further key rulings in the litigation or the appeal.